You have probably seen the headline this week: U.S. home sales fell to their lowest level in 16 years. The number is real, and it is worth understanding what it actually measures - and why the price drops many people expect have not shown up.What the headline actually saysThe National Association of real estate agents reported Thursday that sales of previously owned homes fell 5.5% in October from September, to a seasonally adjusted annual pace of 3.75 million. That is 8.8% below October of last year and the slowest pace since August 2010. Sales fell in the Midwest, South and West; the Northeast held steady. Note what this number is: the count of homes changing hands. It is not a price index.What prices are actually doingThe same report put the median price of homes that actually sold at $416,700, up just 0.4% from a year ago - the smallest annual gain since February. That median reflects the mix of homes that happened to sell, not the changing value of the same homes, so it can hold steady even while some individual home values slip. Nationally, the median sold price is essentially flat. Median asking prices tell a softer story - down about 2% from last year - and roughly one in five active listings took a price cut in October, the highest October share since 2022. Some metros are weaker than others. But a broad national decline in the median sold price has not happened so far.Reason one: ratesThe 30-year mortgage rate reached about 7.4% in October, the highest since 2023; the Federal Reserve raised its benchmark interest rate in September. At that rate, the monthly payment on a median-priced home shuts out a lot of buyers. When buyers step back, sales fall first.Reason two: the economyInflation, the Iran war, and job-security worries have made both buyers and sellers cautious. Big financial decisions get postponed when the news feels unstable, and housing is the biggest financial decision most families make.Reason three: sellers are pulling back instead of repricingHere is my straight answer to why prices have held up so far. In a normal slowdown, weak demand pushes sellers to cut prices until buyers return. Many sellers today are doing something else: withdrawing. Delistings ran near record highs this spring - 5.8% of listings were pulled in April, the highest since 2020 - and 4.4% of active listings came off the market in October. New listings are down 7.5% from a year ago, so many owners are not listing at all.The staying power is rates. Owners with low fixed-rate mortgages may be less willing to sell and take on a higher-rate loan; those who do not need to move can choose to wait rather than accept a price they do not like. When sellers withdraw rather than reprice, that reduces available supply relative to what it would otherwise be - and that relative tightness is a big part of why prices have not fallen even as sales collapsed. Sellers are not deciding this market's prices; many are simply taking their homes off it.One honest note on the data: October's delisting rate was actually slightly below last year's, and economists at real estate agent.com call this 'a seller pause, not an exodus.' Withdrawals are one major explanation, not the whole story - but they are the behavior behind my answer.The honest qualifierFlat is not the same as rising. Price growth has slowed to a crawl, asking prices are drifting down, and economists warn that if inventory keeps building while rates stay high, prices could stall or slip in some areas. 'Prices are not falling' describes the national median of homes that actually sold - it is not an average, not a same-home price index, and not every market. Local conditions vary.What this means if you are buying or sellingFor sellers: the homes selling in this market are the ones priced at today's market, not last year's. Testing high and then withdrawing is an option only if you genuinely do not need to move. For buyers: you have more choice and more negotiating room than a year ago, especially on listings that have been sitting. The stale listing is where the leverage is.
Parm Rahi
Broker/Owner
Area served: Walnut Creek, Hercules, Concord, CA, Pinole, CA, Pleasant Hill, CA, San Ramon, CA, Danville, CA
Expertise: Transaction Process
