A $29.8 Million Atherton Estate Went Into Contract in 15 Days. Nearly Half the Board Is Now Spoken For.

2 Carolina Lane hit the MLS on October 5 at $29,800,000. By October 20 it was contingent. Fifteen days, near the top of the Atherton board, with the 30-year mortgage sitting north of 7 percent.That one got my attention, so this morning I went through Coldwell Banker's Atherton page listing by listing. Of the 24 listings it showed, 11 were pending or contingent. The asks on those 11 add up to roughly $137.6 million. A few I've written about already, Stockbridge and Encinal among them. Five are new to this column, and they went under contract in October.Carolina is the big one. Brent and Mary Gullixson at Compass have it. Built in 2003, 11,300 square feet, seven bedrooms, an elevator across three levels, a tennis and pickleball court, a putting green, a batting cage and a poolside guest house, on 55,252 square feet per MLSListings. That's about $2,637 a foot on the house and $539 a foot of land. MLS ML82063561. Contingent means contingencies are still open, so I'd hold off on calling it a sale until it records.59 Somerset Lane was faster. Keri Nicholas at Parc Agency listed it October 12 at $16,800,000, a 1994 Spanish of 6,732 square feet with five bedrooms and a pool, on about 1.09 acres near the Menlo Circus Club. A broker feed still showed it active on October 15, and Coldwell Banker had it pending by its October 16 update. Call it four days. About $2,496 a foot. MLS ML82064319.265 Atherton Avenue, the 2015 French Normandy one-story Judy and Talia Citron have at Compass, listed September 21 at $15,572,000 and showed pending by October 2. Main house 5,212 square feet plus a 782-square-foot guest house, on 42,537 square feet. Roughly $2,988 a foot on the main house alone, $2,598 counting the guest house. Public record shows a 2012 grant deed at $4,900,000, before the current house went up. MLS ML82062045.Nora Way is the pair I keep looking at. Same street, two half-acre lots, both Atherton addresses on the Redwood City Elementary side.59 Nora Way is a 1952 ranch, 3,155 square feet, four bedrooms, a detached studio with a sauna, and a three-hole putting green out back, on 22,545 square feet. The Gullixsons listed it September 25 at $6,500,000. It went pending October 21, 26 days later. It last sold in August 2015 for $3,300,000, so the ask was about 1.97 times that. MLS ML82062668.29 Nora Way was built in 2018, single level, 3,426 square feet, five bedrooms, on 22,714 square feet. Cam Thompson at Coldwell Banker has it at $8,795,000. Coldwell Banker shows it pending and Douglas Elliman shows contract signed. MLS ML82064569. One caveat, the list dates on the public feeds don't agree, so I'm leaving out how long it took.Those two lots are within about 170 square feet of each other. The newer house asked $2,295,000 more. On a half acre in central Atherton, that gap is roughly what the market is putting on a recent single-level build versus a 1950s ranch you'd likely redo, and the ranch still found a buyer in under four weeks.Altos Research's Tuesday pull for Atherton (October 27) has 21 single-family actives, median list $10,500,000, median days on market 28, and a Market Action Index of 42, up from 38 a month ago. Altos still calls it a slight seller's advantage. Fourteen percent of its board has a price cut. Altos counts its own way, so don't expect its 21 to match the Coldwell Banker count.Freddie Mac's 30-year average was 7.32 percent on October 22. The next print is Thursday. Anything at these prices is a jumbo loan or cash, and whoever is buying Carolina didn't wait on a Thursday number.Plenty is still sitting. 267 Atherton Avenue at $35 million, 99 Tallwood Court at $23 million, 51 Valley Road at $22 million and 1 Edge Road at $19 million all showed active this morning.Town note. The Planning Commission meets Wednesday, October 28 at 6 PM, in person at Town Hall and on Zoom. The agenda wasn't posted on the Town site when I checked.I've done SB9 deals in Atherton, and half-acre lots like the ones on Nora Way come up in those conversations. Whether a split works turns on the specific parcel, the town's current rules and the owner-occupancy affidavit, so get planning staff's read before you price it into an offer. General information only. Have an attorney review anything recorded.Michael Williams is a Bay Area agent with Golden Gate Luxury (Turbohome Inc). Seventeen years in, more than $250M closed, formerly #1 at Flyhomes and Aalto, DRE #01780513. Golden Gate Luxury is not affiliated with Golden Gate Sotheby's.General market commentary only. Nothing here is legal, tax, or financial advice. Listing details, sale records, and market stats change; verify current MLS and public records before acting on any of it.Also on Medium: https://medium.com/@michael_30207/a-29-8-million-atherton-estate-went-into-contract-in-15-days-003c1e0d7cd7
Michael Williams Luxury Specialist Area served: San Francisco, CA, Atherton, San Mateo County, CA, Menlo Park, San Mateo County, CA, Palo Alto, Santa Clara County, CA, Burlingame, San Mateo County, CA, Hillsborough, San Mateo County, CA, San Mateo, CA, San Carlos, San Mateo County, CA, Redwood City, San Mateo County, CA, Woodside, San Mateo County, CA, Belmont, San Mateo County, CA, Portola Valley, San Mateo County, CA Expertise: First-Time Buyer, Luxury, Zoning Knowledge
#MillionAthertonEstate#Million#Atherton#Estate#Contract#Nearly#Board#Spoken#MarketUpdate#JustSold#HomeBuying#HomeSelling
A $29.8 Million Atherton Estate Went Into Contract in 15